Summer Melons vs Winter Melons: Know the Difference

Melons are a favorite in the summer garden, but not all melons are created equal. Knowing the difference between summer melons and winter melons can help you plan your garden more effectively and enjoy a longer harvest season. While all melons are grown during the warm season, their time to maturity and harvest windows vary significantly.

Table of Contents

What Are Summer Melons?

Summer melons are typically ready for harvest from mid to late summer. This group includes muskmelons, cantaloupes, and watermelons. These melons mature relatively quickly—usually in 70 to 90 days—and are best enjoyed fresh off the vine when the weather is hot.

Popular Summer Melon Varieties:

Cantaloupes (muskmelons): ‘Ambrosia’, ‘Burpee Hybrid’, ‘Earlisweet’
Green-fleshed melons: ‘Galia’, ‘Jenny Lind’, ‘Passport’
Watermelons: Not covered in depth here, but also considered summer melons

What Are Winter Melons?

Despite the name, winter melons are not grown in winter—they’re grown during the summer but harvested later, from late summer into fall. These melons have a longer growing season, often needing 100 to 115 frost-free days to fully mature. They’re called “winter melons” because some varieties store well and can be enjoyed into the winter months.

Common Winter Melon Types:

Casaba: Wrinkled golden-yellow rind, subtly sweet white flesh
Crenshaw: Juicy, salmon-colored flesh, spicy-sweet flavor
Honeydew: Smooth-skinned, pale rind with sweet green flesh
Persian: Large, netted rind with musky orange flesh
Charentais: Small French heirloom with fragrant orange flesh

Shared Growing Requirements

Whether you’re growing summer or winter melons, they share many of the same cultural needs:

Warm soil: Plant after the danger of frost has passed
Full sun: At least 6–8 hours daily
Well-drained soil: Melons prefer sandy loam enriched with compost
Consistent moisture: Especially during fruit set and swelling
Space to spread: Vines can sprawl 6–10 feet or more

Winter melons may require slightly more attention due to their longer growing season and greater susceptibility to cold damage near harvest.

Choosing Melon Varieties for Your Garden

To make the most of your melon patch, grow both summer and winter varieties. This staggered approach allows you to enjoy sweet, juicy fruit from mid-summer into fall. Here’s a breakdown by flesh type and variety:

Orange-Fleshed Summer Melons:

‘Ambrosia’, ‘Burpee Hybrid’, ‘Bush Star’, ‘Harper Hybrid’, ‘Superstar’

Green-Fleshed Summer Melons:

‘Galia’, ‘Passport’, ‘Jenny Lind’, ‘Rocky Sweet’

Honeydew Types (Late Season/Winter Melons):

‘Honeydew’, ‘Tam Dew’, ‘Morning Dew’, ‘Early Dew’, ‘Venus’

Other Winter Melons:

‘Crenshaw’, ‘Golden Beauty Casaba’, ‘Honeyshaw’, ‘Marygold’

In Summary

Understanding the difference between summer and winter melons isn’t just about harvest time—it’s about planning for variety, flavor, and storage. Summer melons are your go-to for quick returns and immediate sweetness. Winter melons take a bit more patience but reward you with longer shelf life and distinctive flavor profiles.

Plant both, and you’ll enjoy a steady supply of melons from July through the first frosts of autumn.

🥒 Melon Planting Guide: Summer & Winter Melons 🍈

Grow juicy, flavorful melons all season long

🌱 WHEN TO PLANT

Summer Melons (Cantaloupes, Muskmelons, Watermelons):
Sow seeds or transplant 2–3 weeks after last frost, when soil is at least 70°F (21°C).
Winter Melons (Honeydew, Crenshaw, Casaba):
Start early—sow indoors 4 weeks before the last frost or direct seed as soon as the soil is warm. They need 100–115 frost-free days.

☀️ GROWING CONDITIONS

Sunlight: Full sun (6–8+ hours/day)
Soil: Loose, fertile, well-draining soil (pH 6.0–6.8)
Spacing:
- Hills: 2–3 seeds per hill, spaced 3–4 feet apart
- Rows: Thin to 1 plant every 18–24 inches, rows 5–6 feet apart
Watering: Keep soil consistently moist (not soggy), especially during flowering and fruiting
Feeding:
- At planting: Mix in compost or aged manure
- Mid-season: Feed with a balanced fertilizer or side-dress with compost tea

📅 DAYS TO MATURITY

Melon Type	Days to Harvest
Cantaloupe	70–90 days
Galia	75–80 days
Watermelon	70–100 days
Honeydew	90–110 days
Crenshaw	100–115 days
Casaba	100–115 days

🍈 TIPS FOR SWEETER MELONS

Reduce watering slightly as fruit ripens (too much water can dilute sugars)
Let fruit fully ripen on the vine—most varieties won’t sweeten after harvest
Use mulch to retain soil warmth and moisture

🧺 HARVESTING

Summer melons: Slip easily from the vine when ripe
Winter melons: Do not slip—harvest when the skin changes color and the blossom end softens slightly

Melons Overview: The Ultimate Guide to Growing Melons: From Planting to Harvest

Watermelons: How to Grow Watermelons from Seed to Harvest: Ultimate Guide for Sweet, Juicy Success

Related Posts:

Planting & Growing Basics

Care & Maintenance

Space-Saving Techniques

Ripeness & Harvesting

Melon Types & Varieties